this post was submitted on 27 Nov 2025
722 points (95.0% liked)
me_irl
6933 readers
733 users here now
All posts need to have the same title: me_irl it is allowed to use an emoji instead of the underscore _
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Appeal to nature fallacy
Are you implying that people aren't animals?
No, drag's implying people don't have to do something just because it's natural. Dying of dysentery is natural, but we try to avoid that. That's why your argument that we should eat meat because it's natural is silly
Eating isn't natural? Dying or dysentery is natural, that's why people still die of dysentery. My argument that animals eat meat isnt silly
Drag believes you that animals eat meat, but that's not a good reason for humans to eat meat. That would be an appeal to nature fallacy. Dingos eat babies, but humans shouldn't.
Humans are animals. It's not an appeal to nature fallacy we are animals lol. Are humans somehow special are we better than the rest of nature? We're superior or something?
We have the potential to be. Our big brains let us make ethical choices. Vegans are better than animals, yeah. But you're not. Because you don't use your big brain to make ethical choices. Your choices are what define your goodness, and you don't seem to believe you have a choice.
I'm happy to see you're not full of yourself! Tell you what lets send you up to the north where plants don't grow and let me know how long you wait till you eat meat.
Drag will be fine, drag'll just resort to eating carnists
So murder and cannibalism, and meat eating? Fucking lol. Way to denigrate the first nations by being "better" than them.
Well they didn't have selfish white people to eat until recently, so for them it couldn't be helped.
So vegans "aren't" superior beings? Lol
Drag thinks tribal societies tended to do the best they could, just like modern vegans. Selfish white people who drive cars everywhere and eat factory farmed meat are not doing the best they could, so drag would rank them as less ethical than vegans and most indigenous peoples.
Only selfish white people?