this post was submitted on 25 Aug 2023
11 points (100.0% liked)
Soil Science
690 readers
2 users here now
Welcome to c/soilscience @ slrpunk.net!
A science based community to discuss and learn all things related to soils.

Notice Board
This is a work in progress, please don't mind the mess.
Subdisciplines of soil science include:
- Soil Taxonomy & mapping
- Soil Fertility & Organic Amendments
- Soil Chemistry & Remediation
- Soil Mineralogy
- Soil Physics
- Soil Biology
These subdisciplines are used by various other disciplines, particularly those related to reclamation, remediation, and agriculture.
Rules
- Don't throw mud. Be kind and remember the human.
- Keep it rooted (on topic).
- Please use a tag.
- No spam.
- Memes are welcome, but the focus of this community is science-based
Resources
Blogs
Careers
Chemistry
- Secondary and micronutrient availability by pH
- Secondary and micro nutrients availability by pH line graph
- Common Nutrient Deficiency Symptoms on Leaves Infographic
Classification
Maps & Datasets
Canada
- Canadian System of Soil Classificaiton
- 1982 Canadian Manual for Describing Soils in the Field
- Alberta Soil Quality Criteria Relative to Disturbance this one is widely used across Canada
- Best management practices for conservation of reclamation materials in the mineable oil sands region of Alberta - a good guide to basic reclamation and revegetation BMPs
Europe
- Agrifood Soilscapes (UK)
- Datasets from the BGS (UK)
- Datasets from the James Sutton Institute (UK)
- Scotland Environment Soil Maps
- Soil Atlas of Europe
- UK Geochemical Atlas
- UK Soil Observatory
United States
World
Soil Contamination:
- Cornell Guide to Testing Contaminated Soils
- CCME Soil Guidelines for Contaminants
- Wikipedia Lists of Hyperaccumulators for Bioremediation

Similar Communities
- !geology@lemmy.ca
- !geophysics@lemmy.ca
- !geologycareers@lemmy.ca
- !mining@lemmy.ca
- !openscience@lemmy.ml
- !reclamation@slrpnk.net
Sister Communities
Science and Research
Biology and Life Sciences
- !anthropology@mander.xyz
- !microbiology@mander.xyz
- !biodiversity@mander.xyz
- !palaeoecology@mander.xyz
- !palaeontology@mander.xyz
Plants and Gardening
Physical Sciences
Humanities and Social Sciences
- !archaeology@mander.xyz
- !cooking@mander.xyz
- !folklore@mander.xyz
- !history@mander.xyz
- !old_maps@mander.xyz
Memes
Find us on Reddit
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
When you use the word "fill", I just imagine a topsoil ripped off of a development and then re-sold. Probably a candidate for compaction in a bed. You are probably way better placed than me to comment, but supplied soils to raised beds tend to be higher in organics and structure is lost over time, even the sunken logs would be at risk.
I've posted about structural soil before, the gravel one if you remember. There are many types, here is one called Amsterdam Tree Sand - https://www.cpa-horticulture.co.uk/urban-tree-soil
Here is an search engine AI having a crack at it. The AI is literally defining it in the urban sense, involving pedestrian and cars, whereas I'm describing for containers:
Structural soil is a type of soil used for planting trees in urban environments. It is designed to provide a load-bearing substrate that can support pedestrian and vehicle traffic while also allowing for root growth[4][5]. Structural soil is composed of a mixture of gap-graded gravels, mostly made of crushed stone, and soil with mineral and organic content[5]. The gravel provides load-bearing capacity, while the soil provides nutrients and water for the tree roots to grow[2].
Structural soil is typically used in areas where trees are planted near sidewalks or roads, where the soil is often compacted and unable to support healthy root growth[4]. The soil is compacted to pavement design and installation requirements while still allowing for root growth[5].
CU-Structural Soil® is a specific type of structural soil that was developed by Cornell University’s Urban Horticulture Institute in the 1990s[1][5]. It is composed primarily of specifically sized gravel blended with a loamy soil that allows it to be compacted and placed beneath sidewalks, streets, and other pavement[4]. Trees growing in CU-Structural Soil™ in areas that normally use irrigation to grow trees should also provide low volume drip irrigation in CU-Structural Soil™ [3].
Using structural soil to support trees helps them develop healthy roots and grow to their full potential[6]. It also helps prevent tree roots from cracking or damaging concrete or asphalt[4]. Structural soil was once the standard for planting trees in urban environments due to its ability to sustain healthy tree growth in challenging conditions[2].
Citations: [1] http://www.hort.cornell.edu/uhi/outreach/pdfs/CU-Structural%20Soil%20-%20A%20Comprehensive%20Guide.pdf [2] https://citygreen.com/what-is-structural-soil/ [3] http://www.hort.cornell.edu/uhi/outreach/pdfs/custructuralsoilwebpdf.pdf [4] https://riversandinc.com/soil/structural-soil/ [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structural_Soil [6] https://www.minickmaterials.com/blog/using-structural-soil-to-improve-urban-environments
Your definition of fill is accurate, but it's me who is being obtuse.
What I mean to say, is subsoil (B or C horizon) and then improving that with amendments. You wouldn't want compacted stuff though. In mining they use overburden (C horizon below 1 m) and amend it. They will also use suitable tailings sand or waste rock.
What you described as structural soil is very similar to the composition of waste rock, though waste rock is not as well sorted. Generally it's in the medium to coarse gravel range.
The issue with high amounts of coarse fragments is that it tends to limit water holding capacity. However, I've seen reclamation (first hand) where they rough mounded (created a micro-hummocky landscape) that supported 10 years of tree growth.
You're talking about wild areas, I'm talking bout high input/output raised garden beds in a yard. The water issue is moot because it's something that is looked after on the regular.
Urban trees/plants grown in compacted areas are like giant containers.
https://www.biochar-journal.org/en/ct/77
https://auf.isa-arbor.com/content/48/3/176
Honestly, you probably know more about urban soils and gardening than I do. There's a bunch of weird shit that's been done in that sphere like Silva cells (I think that's what they are called).
You're right about the warring though lmao. Funny how we have our own very different frames of reference, and mine causes me to over look something simple like that.
That's the ones. Same shit, preventing urban compaction processes.
If we use Amsterdam Tree Sand (used since the 80s) as an example, the pore space is a lot smaller but the use case is the same:
Why use tree pit sand?
-Specifically developed to resist compaction -Enables the tree pit to withstand heavy footfall -Allows the free flow of oxygen and moisture and improves drainage -Promotes healthy, strong root growth -Prevents damage to pavements or roads through subsidence
Why I might call it structural for a raised bed is that subsidence in a fixed space is a reduction in pore space which is compaction. An aerated structure topped off with organics will fill with silt and roots and then one would hope that worms will keep those open. Being an edible bed, there will be a lot of dieback of roots as well.
There are some nurseries moving to inorganic media, so no organics whatsoever. Sand, pumice, peat (classed as inorganic due to slow breakdown), biochar etc. Better growth, less anaerobia as mixes break down equals longer in pot without health concerns (nutrient supplied in water). A raised bed of 700mm (more than 2ft), a lot of that lower area is under weight pressures too, herbs/edibles can't really access that. Structural soils may prevent anaerobic lower layers somewhat while keeping drainage high. The top 10-15cm is where all the action happens anyway.