this post was submitted on 30 Oct 2025
10 points (91.7% liked)

Ask Electronics

3881 readers
4 users here now

For questions about component-level electronic circuits, tools and equipment.

Rules

1: Be nice.

2: Be on-topic (eg: Electronic, not electrical).

3: No commercial stuff, buying, selling or valuations.

4: Be safe.


founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Is this feasible at all?

My idea is to have a battery of 112 Li Ion cells in series, ending up with a nominal voltage of about 414V. This is apparently how car batteries are configured as well and it's the easiest for an EGS002 inverter.

Charging however is quite difficult as stepping up to those voltages is not trivial.

The idea is to have a charge pump circuit on every single cell. 2 mosfets for charging, a capacitor, 2 mosfets for discharging. The capacitor would charge from a 4.2V supply and discharge into the battery.

The mosfets on the battery side can be controlled with optocouplers. The gate voltage is provided by cells further up in the chain so the gate always has at least 12V on it.

Is this a bad idea? Things that come to mind are the mosfet losses. Essentially the on resistance counts 4 times per cell but usually the rDS on is in the 20 mOhm range, so 80 mOhm per cell.

Balancing is much easier this way.

Perhaps a compromise that charges several cells in series and watches the balancing could work too if efficiency is the biggest reason against this.

I'm aware of the safety considerations.

top 2 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[โ€“] litchralee@sh.itjust.works 6 points 1 week ago (1 children)

To start, the idea of charging in parallel while discharging in series is indeed valid. And for multicell battery packs such as for electric automobiles and ebikes, it's the only practical result. That said, the idea can sometimes vary, with some solutions providing the bulk of charging current through the series connection and then having per-cell leads to balance each cell.

In your case, you would have a substantial number of cells in series, to the point that series charging would require high voltage DC, beyond the normal 50-60 VDC that constitutes low-voltage.

But depending on if charging and discharge are mutually exclusive operations, one option would be to electrically break the pack into smaller groups, so that existing charge controllers can charge each group through normal means (ie balancing wires). Supposing that you used 12s charger ICs, that would reduce the number of ICs to about 9 for a pack with a nominal series voltage ~400vdc. You would have to make sure these ICs are isolated once the groups are reconstituted into the full series arrangement.

Alternatively, you could float all the charging ICs, by having 9 rails of DC voltage to supply each of the charging ICs. And this would allow continuous charging and battery monitoring during discharge. Even with the associated circuitry to provide these floating rails, the part count is still lower than having each cell managed by individual chargers and MOSFETs.

It's not clear from your post what capacity or current you intend for this overall pack, but even in small packs, I cannot possibly advise using anything but a proper li-ion charge controller for managing battery cells. The idea of charging a capacitor to 4.2v and then blindly dumping voltage into a cell is fraught with issues, such as lacking actual cell temperature monitoring or even just charging the cell in a healthy manner. Charge IC are designed specifically designed for the task, and are just plain easier to build into a pack while being safer.

[โ€“] Rolive@discuss.tchncs.de 1 points 1 week ago

The idea of the battery pack is to provide energy for a household. The reason I'm considering such a large amount in series is that it would make an inverter much more efficient and easy to make. An EGS002 based circuit for example relies on a 400V DC, which I find very difficult to make out of lower voltages. Especially when high wattages are involved. There are no DC-DC converters commercially available with around 55V input (16s li-ion) and 400V output at 4KW. There are however commercial inverters available such as the Victron Multiplus II 48V that can deliver about 4000W of AC. This would suit my needs however I want to DIY as much as possible. I also have plans for a self made solar charge controller and possibly even a wind controller as extra modules next to the battery charging circuit and inverter.

Solving the issue of converting high power 55V to 400V DC would remove the need for a high-series battery pack as well.

Indeed blindly dumping the charge into a battery is not the intention. There will be additional circuitry to prevent cells from overheating and to limit the inrush current that they receive but the general idea is a capacitor that floats between 4.2V and Vcell.