I disagree, they call 10 holdings a game and Jets fans still watch.
NFL
A place for NFL news, game highlights and everything that excites you about American Football.
They don't miss holdings when the Jets are on offense.
Holdings
It would be boring, but safer, if holding was legal.
For more fun, make holding illegal while tackling as well. That ought to boost the offense.
Every penalty which results in a new set of downs or causes change of possession should be reviewable and challengable (and not like that one time the PI calls, use the sky judge and those make the decisions)
Unironically this
Just wish there was at least consistency. Like it's become more about when you are called for holding. First down after an incompletion? Not a problem for a lot of teams. On a 20 yard completion on 3rd and 8 on a ticket tack hold that makes you think the ref knew he'd call it prior to the play? That'll kill a drive and possibly flip a game
It would be offensive for the players to follow the rules. I agree.
#firegoodell
It is still irritating though. It really does seem like Micah gets held on every single play. Like.. multiple literal chokeholds a game..
Good lol
You could point to all the great pass rushers, I see it all the time against JJ and Q on the Jets because I watch them more, but you also see it constantly against Crosby, Hutch, Watt, Garrett, Bosa…
Feels like the inconsistency just removes the advantage of having great pass rushers. That is a literal game changer for the Jets because you know damn well the Offense isn’t gonna do anything, so to see your DL getting mugged just makes it, like you said, irritating.
The plays that look like chokeholds are usually not actually holding. You get to that position usually when the pass rusher does a rip move, which basically pushes the O-lineman's arm up into a position where they have to either disengage or wrap their arm around the pass rusher. There's an exception in the rulebook for those plays.
As a fan of a player that loves them: still. There are holds on those players, and the league doesn’t call them.
"The NFL fined Micah Parsons $150,000 for unsportsmanlike language"
The automatic first down penalties need to be abolished,
League bails out certain teams in the 4th quarter every week .
There isn’t an equivalent for the defensive side.. like, imagine offensive holding meant 5 yard penalty and automatic 4th down.
It’s demoralizing and game changing
Every. Single. Week.
Crucial drives that are in a 3rd down for certain teams always get a defensive holding, illegal contact, or a very late thrown PI flag that gives an automatic first down, which then changes the outcome of the game.
gotta PROTECT the SHIELD
“…and a cool $1mil for tossing up the deuces while saying it”
Micah fails to realize the more he bitches about refs, the less likely they are to actually call holds that benefit him
I’ve accepted it’s useless, the mf will not stop tweeting. Once the mf openly admits to having a foot fetish when he absolutely did not have to you know he dgaf
How is this bitching? I guess he is acknowledging that the missed holds exists, but everyone knows that. It’s not a secret. Seems like he’s either agreeing or at least understands their reasoning for not calling every single one.
Its also boring when shit offensive play gets bailed out late with some grab ass PI call that was allowed throughout the entire game
Offensive holding is the worst.
It can be called on every snap...so the refs can use it to control the flow of a game. Sometimes they swallow their whistles.
Worst is when "Team A" is expected to win by a decent margin but it feels like the league wants a nail-biter. They'll start calling holding on every big play Team A gets so that they stay in 3rd & long situations. Team B hangs in the game long enough to make it interesting. Refs will throw some random penalties at Team B later in the game to even up the flags.
Team B gets a bunch of ticky tack calls and thinks the league conspired against them late in the game. Team A feels like they got a bunch of momentum killing calls early....and would have blown out Team B otherwise.
Or defensive holding. Especially if it’s in a big game in a crucial situation that essentially ends an exciting game in the most boring way possible. Just as a hypothetical and I’m not still mad at all.
Such as a certain Super Bowl game
Hey now that strategy kept Matt Canada working for 2+ years
We're actually below league average on the number of PIs called on our opponents. You generally have to pass downfield to get PI flags and Canada doesn't stand for that nonsense.
What’s offensive is bad reffing
This is a good way to make sure the refs never call a hold in your favor again.
If you remember a few years ago they did this, and the viewership went down and everyone bitched. It was insane how many holding calls they were calling.
The only annoying thing about it now is how selective it is. Realistically almost every play could have a holding call, so they only call the ones that are obvious. I think everyone is okay with that, but the problem is that sometimes a less obvious one has a significant effect but doesn’t get called or a more obvious one has little to no effect and does get called.
The solution definitely isn’t to just throw that shit every time they see it, because that would be most plays, but right now I feel like reffing has to be changed somehow because it’s been awful
OL holding should be officiated differently. More like penalties in basketball. The line gets a set number of allowed holds per half and after that each one is a called penalty.
Yes that means they could hold more early on, but that would risk a higher likelihood of holding penalties in key moments at the end of halves when it’s more valuable.
Say the number is 5 allowed per team per half. There are 35 offensive plays per team each half. So the OL can only “get away” with holding on 14% of them, which I think we can all agree is less than the percentage of holds teams currently get no-calls on.
You could build in safeguards against abuses as well like; no exceptions under 2 minutes.
This would also allow linemen to learn how the refs will be calling holding for that particular game.
If this worked for OL Holding it could also work for PI.
Respectfully, nothing should ever do what the NBA does, under any circumstance ever.
The NFL and NBA already share the fact that they are entertainment entities meant to make profits first, competitive sports leagues that are meant to find the best team second.
They should change the holding penalty to 5 yards instead of 10. Maybe they’d be inclined to call more holds consistently. 10 yards is a huge penalty to recover from.
The whole "refs would be throwing flags the whole game" comment is so nearsighted. Maybe that would happen a few games, but 10 yard penalties are absolute drive killers, call enough of those and offensive linemen will begin not relying on refs to overlook holds.