Supernova1051

already blocked lemmy.ml 🥳

Create your own damn communities with black jack and hookers instead.

Exactly what I'm doing. Just adding to the mountains of evidence. On a side note, I just tried the Piefed on the Interstellar app on Android and I'm really liking it. Link for anyone interested: https://interstellar.jwr.one/install/

What metadata does XMPP leak?

• Sender's Full Jabber ID (JID): This is typically in the format user@domain.com/resource. The user@domain.com part identifies the user and their home server, and the /resource identifies the specific client device they are using (e.g., alice@example.com/mobile or alice@example.com/laptop).
• Recipient's Full Jabber ID (JID): Similar to the sender's, this specifies who the message is intended for, including their user, home server, and often the specific resource.
• Sender's Server: The domain of the sender's JID reveals which XMPP server the sender is connected to.
• Recipient's Server: The domain of the recipient's JID reveals which XMPP server the message is being routed to.
• Timestamp of Message Transmission: Servers record when a message was sent, which can be used to infer activity patterns.
• Approximate Message Size: While the exact content is encrypted, the size of the encrypted stanza can still be observed. This can sometimes give clues about the type of content (e.g., a small text message - versus a larger file transfer).
• Message Type (e.g., chat, group chat, presence, IQ): XMPP uses different stanza types for various purposes. Even with E2EE, the type of stanza (e.g., a "message" stanza vs. a "presence" stanza) is visible.
• Participation in Group Chats: If a user is part of a Multi-User Chat (MUC), the MUC service and the user's participation in it are known to the MUC server and potentially other participants' servers.
• Presence Information: XMPP inherently broadcasts presence (online/offline status, "away" messages, etc.) to contacts. This reveals when a user is active.
• Contact List (Roster) Information: While not "leaked" during every message, the XMPP server hosts and manages the user's contact list, meaning the server knows who a user is communicating with.
• Device Information (Resource): As mentioned, the /resource part of the JID can reveal the type of client or device being used.

I find it strange that Signal somehow doesn’t know when a message was sent

Signal uses Sealed Sender (wired.com). Imagine if letters you sent didn't require a "from" field - or it was inside the envelope and impossible for anyone to see it. The post office would only know who its going to and only the recipient can decrypt it (open the letter) to see who sent it. Now, you could say, well they have your IP and can correlate it to the account, but the easy way around this is to either use a VPN or Signal proxy (support.signal.org) if you're that paranoid.

how would they ever make this possible?

Read more about it here: Technology preview: Sealed sender for Signal (signal.org)

How about most e-mail providers? Not Google and Microsoft of course, but most e-mail providers only need a name which can be made up as well

Most email providers suffer similar metadata leaks as XMPP because:

• 1. Email was created in the 70's and we've learned a lot since then about privacy and security.
• 2. XMPP works off a similar concept where you inherently pass data along to another server.

You could host your own email, XMPP, or Matrix server - that's definitely a win for privacy. But as soon as you interact with someone outside your ecosystem (server), metadata leakage is an issue again. It's why making end-to-end encrypted email is a hard problem to solve. It's not that it can't be secure, its that it has to work with those that aren't because that's the expectation.

... host your own email server, then you are in control

Until you interact with others who aren't using encryption or have it misconfigured.

great advice. do you know if there's any kind of "getting started" guide for lemmy? Would be great if step 1 is to block lemmy/lemmygrad and specific/known users.

FYI yogthos is also on Mastodon, blocking yogthos[@]social.marxist.network should do the trick.

devil's avocado: this move has saved many people's cherished photos from disappearing by having them auto save. before Google photos I'd run into cases (I used to do home IT support) where people had years of family photos disappear because they didn't back them up properly. Having to communicate what happened was never fun.

is Google photos perfect? No, but it's a great solution for people who don't want to manage their data.

fully aware! just don't care much since its so cheap ($270 for 20 TB!) and my last externals (two 10 TBs) served without issue for ~5 years. Just gotta make sure you have backups and upgrade every few years.

I can see why you'd draw those comparisons to "spontaneous generation" or "God of the Gaps" -- it's a common misconception when people first encounter the idea of emergence. However, that's not quite what Emergentism, especially in the context of consciousness, is suggesting.

The key difference is that emergent properties aren't truely "spontaneous" or without a basis in the underlying components. Instead, they arise from complex interactions between those components, often in ways that are not easily predictable from studying the individual parts alone.

Think of it like this:

• Water's wetness: A single H2O molecule isn't wet. Wetness emerges from the collective behavior and interactions of many water molecules. We don't say wetness is "spontaneous generation" of a property, but rather a property of the system.
• A hurricane: A hurricane is a complex, self-organizing system with emergent properties like its destructive power and eye. These properties aren't found in individual air molecules or even small air currents; they emerge from the large-scale interactions of atmospheric conditions.

In the context of consciousness, an emergentist perspective suggests that consciousness isn't located in a single neuron or even a small group of neurons, but rather emerges from the intricate network activity and complex interactions of billions of neurons in the brain. It's not about throwing our hands up and saying 'it just happens.' It's about recognizing that complexity can give rise to novel properties that aren't reducible to the sum of their parts.

The challenge isn't a lack of evidence that something is happening (we clearly observe consciousness), but rather the difficulty in fully understanding and mapping the incredibly complex mechanisms that lead to this emergent phenomenon. It's an active area of research, and while we don't have all the answers, it's a far cry from "God of the Gaps" because it proposes a naturalistic, albeit complex, explanation rather than invoking something supernatural.

While theories like Orch-OR offer a different approach, many neuroscientists find the emergentist framework more consistent with how complex systems behave in other areas of science.

I've been running my server on an old laptop and a 20TB external hard drive connected via USB. it's not fast, there's a multi-second delay when the drive goes to "sleep" if nobody has used jellyfin in a while, which makes it appear to not work, but once it spins up it works like normal. this has let me keep things simple and cheap. I back up to another 20TB hard drive, which I recently bought as I could finally afford it. beefy hardware is great but not necessary, if you're okay with some limits.

I just want to take a second to thank my 7 supporters, it means the world to me.

But to all the haters out there who don't appreciate the 2 seconds it took to generate this masterpiece... bless your hearts 🥰

The voting system (first-past-the-post) + electoral college (DEI for conservatives who are easily manipulated by the upper class) + gerrymandering (REDMAP) make it nearly impossible for a third party to win. See Duverger's law.

I wouldn't completely rule it out. I suspect it's much easier to "taint" and disrupt smaller communities. A lot less resources could be strategically used against lemmy - or any other small platform - at their early growth stage.