this post was submitted on 23 Jan 2025
21 points (100.0% liked)
Melbourne
2123 readers
58 users here now
This community is a place created for the people of Melbourne and Victoria. We are a positive, welcoming and inclusive community. We might not agree about everything, but we always strive to stay civil and respectful.
The focus of our discussions is based around things that affect Victoria, but we are also free to discuss our local perspective on wider issues. Or head to the regular Daily Random Discussion thread to talk about anything.
Ongoing discussions, FAQs & Resources (still under construction)
Adoption Certificate for Nellie, the Daily Thread numbat (with thanks to @Catfish)
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Vanilla slice, lamington, pavlova, hedgehog slice, lemon slice, mint slice, jelly slice? Which Aussie treat would you pick?
Depends who's making it! The kitchen manager at work occasionally brings in a jelly slice and it's just magnificent. I don't know what she does but it's divine. No lamingtons have ever topped the size and freshness of the ones I used to get in primary school on their annual fundraising lamington drive. I adore hedgehog, but there are too many dry lacklustre examples out there, and I've been frequently disappointed. As for pav, a perfect pav is food of the gods but again, so many meh ones out there. And vanilla slice is frequently an abomination, but a really good one is just... Hey can you guys just hang on a sec? (Inches towards front door) I'll, um, I'll be back in a minute, I've just got to, um, put petrol in the car (dashes out door without car keys)
did you know timtams are a pale australian copy of the original French patisserie small biscuit cake
iow, they are all delicious if made well with good ingredients
but I think pavs are most likely to be delicious, pretty hard to ruin fresh cream and fruit
Tim Tam's were based off the english Penguins.
really? okay
Yeah and Tim Tam was named after a race horse.
I don't know who's making them but i can assure you all desserts will be tested by me. And they're all👌
Vanilla slice if I had to pick. Prefer the European versions of it though.
pavlova with cream and fruit
Preferred fruit?
All of them, but especially strawberry, blueberries, mango, passionfruit juice
Both vanilla slice and lamington. Why limit yourself to one. But lamington must have jam.
Seriously considering making lamingtons this weekend.
Jelly slice. Haven't seen one of those for aaaages. They're yum too.
Yes, yes, yes.
Mint slice
Ok I'll have to add this now.
Probably jelly slice but I’m not sure what it is as I haven’t seen one.
Ok. Let me explain. It has a biscuit base like a cheese cake. The middle is like a panna cotta (like a really really weak custard made with condensed milk) and jelly on top. When it's done really well, it beats all the rest because it's not sickly sweet.
YUM
Oh then that’s probably not for me.
Lamington but has to have jam in it.
If you're at a kid's party and a grandmother has made them, give them a go.
Lamingtons MUST have jam.
The panna cotta doesn’t really agree with me.
I don’t like cheesecakes so lamington it is!
I also don't particularly like cheesecake. Bit then there is Roman cheesecake wich is more a whole baked ricotta as MF is fantastic, but a once a decade sort of thing
Fair enough
Pavlova. With strawberry and blueberry and kiwifruit. Or passionfruit puree. I don't really like the others and detest lamingtons. No, I guess I'll never get my Australian citizenship...
Oh hun. You have hurt me deep.
I have accepted my role as the village parish
Hedgehawg
pav
What's your preferred topping?
raspberry and strawberry, or passion fruit.
Vanilla slice by a considerable margin
Can I say fairy bread? Or chocolate ripple cake?
But if I had to pick, probably hedgehog or pavlova. I've never had a jelly slice before!
You can but I was thinking more bakery goodies but this is a game of pretend so why not.
Vanilla slice 4 lyfe
Pavlova in a heartbeat.
No lemon slice?
Shit. I'll add it to the list.
If made by my ex-housmate's partner - hedgehog
In the wild (and this might be influenced by the fact I have not had a good one since having to be GF) vanilla slice
Edit: If I have to cook it: Pav. It's my superpower
I've never made a pav because my mum makes good ones.
If you go to a Gotham Doughnuts they do an awesome V which is a donut cross Vanilla slice in GF. I'm not responsible if you choose other GF delicacies while there.
Oh awesome. I will add that to my list of places to suss out
I've eaten them. You can't tell the difference. 5/5.
Lemon slice, then jelly slice a close second and vanilla third.