this post was submitted on 25 Sep 2025
81 points (98.8% liked)
LV426 - On Lemmy no one can hear you scream
549 readers
2 users here now
This is a community for discussion of the Alien and Predator franchise in the spirit of the /r/lv426 subreddit
Rules
- Be civil
- No trolling
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Interesting how perspectives can vary.
I didn't like it straight away and gave up after Episode 03 (tried to give it a chance). From the comments I've seen, the severe problems present in the first three episodes only got worse later on.
It wasn't great. Which really made me sad because I wanted to love this show.
The most compelling stories happen when it feels like the narrative unfolds due to the characters and their interactions, where A inevitably causes B, which in turn causes C, and so-on.
Watching Alien Earth, it felt like A, B and C were all drawn out in advance, and the characters were simply going through predictable and sometimes bizarre motions to move the plot from one point to the next.
Obviously shows and movies are scripted and written in advance, but the trick is to make it not feel like that to the audience, so we can get invested and live in the moment, with the characters.
And that was the problem with Alien Earth. I barely cared about anyone, I couldn't get invested, and the whole thing felt bland to me.
The biggest exception was Morrow (the Maginot's cyborg security officer) who I thought was a great character, with strong acting performance. The flashback episode to the events on the Maginot prior to the crash which featured him significantly was probably the strongest episode IMO.
The actor who played Morror did a good job at least in the first 3 episodes.
I tried watching Episode 05 (people were recommending it, saying it's self-contained and a throwback to the movies). Turned it off after 10 minutes, it's not for me.
I watched ep 4 last night and I thought it was very boring. The story is interesting but they take a lot of time to build up stuff that don't deliver. The episode could have been an email. I'll probably keep watching tho