david

But the fuzzy bars on the side make it great?!?

Watching portrait footage that's been padded out to landscape on a portrait device is even worse!

I'm proposing that the web designer writes a responsive webpage when they are sent a portrait video to include, so that if it's viewed on a portrait device it fills the width, and when it's viewed on a landscape device it fills the height. If it's actually for telly, there's usually no harm in cropping a bit at the top and bottom and at that point, feel free to put whatever you like down the sides, but there's no need to throw away the portrait original for the portrait view of the website.

Like I already said, the technology for writing a webpage that looks different depending on the orientation of the device being used to view it is neither complicated nor new. There's no need to treat every medium the same in 2023.

I never said it's lower quality. Not once.

No? This you?

we kept everything to a certain standard of quality. Vertical videos are not suitable for anything except a phone.

Totally not lower quality. Definitely not. There's a full stop and everything. No link whatsoever. My bad.

No one said anything about websites.

Well I think the rest of us are discussing a video on bbc.co.uk, which is a website, and we're doing it on lemmy.world, which is also a website, and when I complained about people making portrait videos landscape, I suspect most people correctly figured out that I meant on websites, so I really think it's just you that assumes we're talking about jeep club.

Why can't you use it? Because your web designer isn't designing for the possibility that people use a phone to access the Web, but it's not 2004 any more and they're living in the past.

You showed your colours when you assumed that portrait video is of lower quality. It's only of lower quality if you've padded it out and are watching it on a landscape screen!

Technology to detect whether your webpage is being viewed landscape has existed for a long time, and takes very simple calculations indeed or just a splash or two of css to maximise the video size for whatever screen it's being viewed on. It's design laziness and wasted bandwidth to put the silly blurry bars or even black bars down the side of the video. But don't force landscape on everyone. Smart phones aren't new and they aren't going away.

I suspect that the majority of people who spend even a tiny bit more than half of their recreational screen time looking at a fixed landscape screen are well over thirty.