The women have to have an attractive face. Face>Body. I don't really care for porn with the face hidden but if I can imagine her having a nice face then it could work.
Weird/unattractive guys in a video kill it. Rather just be a "normal" guy that I don't really pay attention to.
I'll be honest, I watch some trans porn sometimes because I really don't care where the dick is attached too. As long as she has a pretty face thats what matters. In a way seeing her pleasure herself with something that I can relate to is much more enjoyable than watching a solo pussy performance (probably my least favorite porn, she would have to have an absolutely beautiful face). I'm imagining any dick I see in porn as my own.
I'm picky too and 90% of my porn experience everytime is searching for "the perfect video". Guess it's like foreplay. I won't generally watch a video again unless I stumble upon it again. I do have some woman that fit my ideal dream girl look and will sometimes search for just them. But I do really enjoy the hunt lol.