Subject 376
Transfem
A community for transfeminine people and experiences.
This is a supportive community for all transfeminine or questioning people. Anyone is welcome to participate in this community but disrupting the safety of this space for trans feminine people is unacceptable and will result in moderator action.
Debate surrounding transgender rights or acceptance will result in an immediate ban.
- Please follow the rules of the lemmy.blahaj.zone instance.
- Bigotry of any kind will not be tolerated.
- Gatekeeping will not be tolerated.
- Please be kind and respectful to all.
- Please tag NSFW topics.
- No NSFW image posts.
- Please provide content warnings where appropriate.
- Please do not repost bigoted content here.
This community is supportive of DIY HRT. Unsolicited medical advice or caution being given to people on DIY will result in moderator action.
Posters may express that they are looking for responses and support from groups with certain experiences (eg. trans people, trans people with supportive parents, trans parents.). Please respect those requests and be mindful that your experience may differ from others here.
Some helpful links:
- The Gender Dysphoria Bible // In depth explanation of the different types of gender dysphoria.
- Trans Voice Help // A community here on blahaj.zone for voice training.
- LGBTQ+ Healthcare Directory // A directory of LGBTQ+ accepting Healthcare providers.
- Trans Resistance Network // A US-based mutual aid organization to help trans people facing state violence and legal discrimination.
- TLDEF's Trans Health Project // Advice about insurance claims for gender affirming healthcare and procedures.
- TransLifeLine's ID change Library // A comprehensive guide to changing your name on any US legal document.
Support Hotlines:
- The Trevor Project // Web chat, phone call, and text message LGBTQ+ support hotline.
- TransLifeLine // A US/Canada LGBTQ+ phone support hotline service. The US line has Spanish support.
- LGBT Youthline.ca // A Canadian LGBT hotline support service with phone call and web chat support. (4pm - 9:30pm EST)
- 988lifeline // A US only Crisis hotline with phone call, text and web chat support. Dedicated staff for LGBTQIA+ youth 24/7 on phone service, 3pm to 2am EST for text and web chat.
i dont get at all
maybe because my region culture
but sometimes "девушка" (young women)
funny that i never get called a boy men last year
i remember child said "тётя" (aunt) but him mother said "это дядя" and he said "тётя" again, so cute, im think child saying what they feel and doesnt look to clotches and every mm of skull
On rare occasions I'll get a "ma'am" from strangers, and I've got one friend who will give me an occasional "darling". But aside from that, nothing but my regular name.
And the only time I've gotten "ladies", it was the waiter addressing me and my masc/NB partner during an anniversary date. That wasn't fun for anyone.
Oof.
One of the times I got a "ladies" I was hanging out with a closeted transmasc friend and they were caught as collateral damage. (To be fair, he is extremely feminine, wears feminine clothes in pastel colors, wears feminine jewelry and earrings, and he hasn't socially or medically transitioned at all, other than to ask the local trans groups to use he/they pronouns for him.)
But it still really sucks, I feel like I'm failing in that moment - there isn't an easy way for me to defend my friend without awkwardly outing him and needlessly alienating a cis person who could not have possibly known he was a closeted transmasc person.
I also get uncomfortable when he goes into the women's restroom with me - like, they are asking me to use "he/they" pronouns for him, but he's also going to go in the women's restroom with me? 🤷♀️ I dunno, it can create some cognitive dissonance for me, even if I also understand being closeted means you are making these kinds of choices.
But I try to be understanding, I know it's hard to come out of the closet and actually transition - hopefully he does soon.
My driving instructor was the only person who I can think of pre transition who called me anything specific, he called me "lad", which I told him multiple times I didn't like and he kept 'forgetting' and using it anyway :(
I've gotten called "that woman over there" (a conversation I overheard), and to my face, Miss and Ma'am. I also get the "ladies" thing when with others, haha!
yay, we're ladies 👏 👏 👏
pre-transition I was mistaken for a girl from behind once and called "miss" by a customer (which caused mixed feelings for me)
but mostly pre-transition I had typical boy and man experiences: "he", "sir", "dude", "bro", etc.
post-transition it is more typical of a young woman, lots of "miss"
when I was visibly trans or people knew I was trans, I would get a lot of "they" (even though I don't like being referred to as "they", particularly when it indicates discomfort or uncertainty from a cis person), or people just not using gendered language for me (I think a lot of this is an attempt to be polite in the face of ambiguity about my gender - they don't want to offend).
Ohh i just call all people who haven't told me othereise "they" to avoid assumptions, even if their gender is 'obvious', I hadn't considered people might not like that ...
ah, to be clear I don't think that's what's going on in my situation; though it is a good point that always using neutral "they" could cause some dysphoria for some people who actually care about being seen as their gender (like, if you did that to me now I may or may not start to feel insecure, like wondering if you clocked that I'm trans or if you're just a liberal, etc.)
I'm talking about an average cis person who isn't trying to be politically correct, who knows I identify as a woman and uses she/her pronouns, but who uses "they" anyway because I'm visibly trans.
Pre-transition: “bro”, “dawg”, “bruh”, “bruu”, “broseph”, “dude” from my friends, endearingly and ironically (I assume) since I’ve always been effeminate. From strangers mostly just “hey! you!” Some people said “brother” unironically and 🤮 unfriended instantly
Currently: when I’m alone I get “buddy” and “sir”, which is weird because basically nobody referred to me as sir pre-transition. But besides that, there’s a lot less direct references to my gender. When I’m with other girls it’s always “ladies” at least.
I hope to someday pass, sounds nice
Currently: when I’m alone I get “buddy” and “sir”, which is weird because basically nobody referred to me as sir pre-transition.
Yeah, welcome to getting older. I get sir'ed and m'amed about 50-50 now depending what I'm wearing. Before that, I frequently got "big guy" (I'm kinda short) 🤮
Girl, bitch, dude (not my fave, but I can deal).
One friend answers my calls, "What's up bitch, getting that pussy pounded?" in reference to Adam Sackler from Girls, lmao.
lol, Adam is such a crazy character 🙃
I had a harder time dealing with "dude" early in transition, but since I no longer look like a dude, I tend to be aware that it's not intended to misgender me, etc.
I don't think I've been called bitch, but my partner and I both call one another "girl" for emphasis 😅
since i live in germany, i don't get any of these very often. it's quite unkommon to use such phrases to adress someone in german. at least in my circles. if you'd approach a friend of yours with "mein*e freund*in" (my friend), they'd probably ask you what tf you want of them. it's not really casual. "bro" is in use but mainly with younger people?
some of my queer friends use "girl" or "diva" for me tho. if speaking english. outside of that specific context "diva" would be a bit of an insult in german. :)
i am still amused about people at work standing in the frame of my office door, asking me for Mr. Soandso. i then smile at them and say "yes come in. that's me." if people don't get visibly confused, i don't feel very misgendered, bc i am playing a role. and when they are it's just super affirming. they are criticizing my performance but affirming my gender. :)))) (need to make it official soon, yeah.)
ja, when people are confused by how you look or can't see a many anymore, you should make it official soon 😅
In Germany aren't professional titles quite common, like "Herr Doktor Professor" kind of stuff? Or is that just in a limited context of a workplace or particular job?
i guess in medicine and law that's still in. :)
The traditional and formal way would be to address someone as "Professor/in Müller" or "Herr/Frau Doktor Müller" but lately no one knows anymore and everyone makes backflips adding in all the titles and honorifics, when trying to be formal, resulting in "Herr/Frau Professor Doktor Müller" or the like. esp. in medicine people will be upset if you dropped the title.
i just used Herr or Frau + Surname (mr./ms.) for my teachers in uni (that was in the humanities). in science and tech people would just call each other by their first names afaik. (note all of these are tendencies)
but a lot of these gendered and neutral words that are used in english quite often have no good equivalent in german, i think. if talking to someone casually, we do not usually call them a lot by words, that illustrate our relationship. (like bro, bestie, girrrrrrrl, son, ...) in greetings/openings it's the name plus maybe horifics and titles. there exist some like "young man", "my friend" (usually male) or "lady" ..., yeah, but i feel this is what old people or vendors use. i cringe at them. ;)
yeah, I'm familiar with the way "Jungs" is used, for example. Can't think of a direct female-equivalent, but I'm not native 🤔
Makes sense that it's mostly formal titles. I think I learned about this mostly in the context of navigating university bureaucracy from the perspective of a professor.
Technically (the best kind of correct), the female equivalent for Jungs would be Mädels, but it's hard to get right.
I'd only use it for a group of girls I'm a part of, and have only heard it used that way. Imagine: "Ich treffe mich heute mit meinen Mädels". (eng.: "I'm going to meet up with my girls.").
I hope this translates well enough to convey my impression that if somebody else uses it, it's inappropriately close language for somebody they may not know that good.
yeah, I think that comes across - "Jungs" also feels weirdly intimate / familiar, like "my bros" or something, or "my boys" ...
Thanks for introducing me to Mädels, it's really helpful to actually talk to someone familiar with the language - I always struggle in my adoption of German because of lack of social context and use. It has really declined over the last 5 years, I'm afraid, I have probably slipped from a B-1 to more like an A-2 level or less 😞
yeah, I think that comes across - “Jungs” also feels weirdly intimate / familiar, like “my bros” or something, or “my boys” …
Yes, I agree. I've actually only ever encountered it in family situations, like when somebody has multiple male kids, or in school.
Thanks for introducing me to Mädels, it’s really helpful to actually talk to someone familiar with the language
It's my pleasure, I'd happily offer my services as a native speaker. I fear that the same is happening to the French I learned until I finished high school.
oh yeah i forgot "jungs" exists. i associate it with sports and other heavily homosocial contexts. female equivalent would be "mädels". i guess "mädels" is gaining acceptance? hm.
i hate both. i may not be the most representative speaker of german. if i had something to say everyone would be addressed with just "hey" or "ummm", depending on if you gonna ask a question. (for all the languages) 😆
I found myself very avoidant of gendered language when I was pre-transition, but once I transitioned it was a complete 180 - now I recognize how important and affirming gender can be, so I'm a big fan of gendered language (when used appropriately, obvi).
Other commenter already noted workplace tendencies, I would like to expand on other parts of life:
Most institutions/corporations insist on you picking a title, though some offer neutral options.
For people you know, it'd be awkward to always adress them at full length, first name is usually enough. This is especially fun whenever you try to greet someone formally when you have just had a nice chat with them about the weekend.
I often get called "ladies" when I'm out with my wife and we're doing women coded activities like shopping for makeup or clothes. Its nice. Most of my friends just call me my name, which I like. I picked a good name.
When I'm out alone I get they/them'd from strangers who try to be supportive, and it hurts a little. Not as much as on the phone when I usually get sir'd. I despise that word. That word sounds contemptuous to me under all circumstances.
Before transition... I try not to think about those times lol
@dandelion When I’m out with my mum I get ‘ladies’ a lot and every time it makes me feel like I’m at some kind of formal debutante ball. 😅
Friends?
hm?